



The Canadian Centre for Housing Rights, National Indigenous Women’s Housing Network, National Right to Housing Network and Women’s National Housing and Homelessness Network are human rights, housing advocacy, and gender justice groups working across Canada to advance the right to housing. We are joining a growing group of over 70 Ontario Councillors, hundreds of members of the legal community and thousands of members of the public to raise the alarm about the recent threats targeted towards some of Ontario’s most marginalized people who are living in encampments, by the Government of Ontario’s potential use of the “notwithstanding clause” to bypass their protected human rights established under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. We are deeply concerned about the dangerous precedent this could set not only for residents of Ontario, but for people across the country.
On October 31, 2024, over a dozen mayors (now fifteen mayors) from across Ontario sent a letter to Ontario Premier Doug Ford, requesting the premier use the clause to allow municipalities to evict people living in encampments in their cities – following an invitation from the premier for mayors to make such a request.
The Charter establishes that people living in Canada have certain rights – including the right to life, liberty and security of person. The Charter says that anyone who feels that the government has not respected these rights can go to the courts to seek a remedy.
In this way, the Charter is a law designed to hold Canadian governments at all levels – federal, provincial and municipal – to account.
If someone brings a Charter complaint, the government has an opportunity to explain itself. The Charter establishes that governments may limit Charter rights if those limitations are “reasonable” and “can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.”
In 2023, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice considered a case where a municipal government sought to evict people from an encampment. The court found that the people living in the encampment did not have appropriate alternate accommodation options, such as affordable housing or shelter, and so eviction would make their “already dire predicament worse.” The court found that eviction would violate the encampment residents’ right to life, liberty and security of person, and so violated the Charter. The Court found that the government action could not be justified as “reasonable” or “demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.”
We are deeply concerned about the attempts by the Premier and these mayors to overturn the precedent that this case set. There is a clause in the Charter – the “notwithstanding clause” – that allows the government to essentially ignore certain parts of the Charter for a period of time. By invoking the notwithstanding clause to evict people from encampments where they do not have appropriate alternative accommodation options, government would be saying that even though its action would make an “already direct predicament worse”… even though its action violates people’s Charter right to life, liberty and security of person… even though courts have already found that this type of eviction could not be justified as “reasonable” or “demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society”… it should be allowed.
If this sounds like a human rights crisis, that’s because it is. The notwithstanding clause should never be used in a situation like this.
If governments were to use the notwithstanding clause to evict people from encampments, it would cause significant harm in two key ways:
1. It would undermine the right to housing, enshrined in Canada’s National Housing Strategy Act (NHSA).
The right to housing means that governments should prioritize the housing needs of the most marginalized, disadvantaged groups in society. Overriding the Charter by using the notwithstanding clause to evict people from encampments when they have no appropriate alternate accommodation options means governments are doing the exact opposite of what they are supposed to do under the NHSA–Canada’s human right to housing legislation. It makes marginalized groups’ “already dire predicament worse” – when really what governments are obligated to do is to maximize the resources they apply to meet the needs of these groups, for example, by building deeply affordable and supportive housing.
Particularly, the use of the notwithstanding clause to evict people from encampments entrenches women and gender-diverse people in unsafe and invisible forms of homelessness. The lack of appropriate alternative accommodation options is more pertinent for women and gender-diverse people who avoid mainstream shelters due to a lack of gender-specific supports and risk to their safety.
For Indigenous people finding shelter in encampments, the use of the notwithstanding clause to evict people from encampments represents an exercise of colonial policies that violate their rights to exercise their agency and self-determination to find sustenance and safety on their homelands.
2. It would undermine the rule of law.
The Charter lays out consequences for governments, when they do not respect the rights of people living in Canada. To ignore these consequences is to undermine the rule of law.
We urge our elected officials to demonstrate their commitment to respect and uphold the right to housing and the Charter rights of all Ontarians through the following actions:
Canadian Centre for Housing Rights – a registered charitable organization, working to advance the right to adequate housing in Canada. We work at the intersection of human rights and housing, providing free services to renters facing evictions and human rights violations to remain housed, providing education and training about housing rights across Canada, and advancing rights-based housing policy through research, policy development, advocacy, and law reform.
National Indigenous Women’s Housing Network – a movement of First Nations, Inuit, and Métis Peoples who are dedicated to improving the living situations of Indigenous women and girls, Two-Spirit, and gender-diverse persons across Turtle Island and ending incidents of becoming unsheltered. All members have the lived experience of needing adequate shelter and a place to call home.
National Right to Housing Network (NRHN) – a broad-based, grassroots civil society network established to fully realize the human right to housing for all in Canada. Launched in February 2020, NRHN is a key resource in guiding Canada’s human rights-based oversight mechanisms—introduced under the National Housing Strategy Act (NHSA) —to address systemic housing inequities which exacerbates the housing and homelessness crisis across the country. Our network of over 2,000 organizational and individual partners work to hold the government accountable and ensure that their human rights commitments made under the NHSA are meaningfully realized.
Women’s National Housing and Homelessness Network – an organization working to advance the diverse voices of women, girls, gender-diverse lived experts, and their allies to lead transformative, gender-specific solutions that reduce and end housing precarity and homelessness through adopting human rights and intersectional feminism approaches.
Cet article est aussi disponible en français

Since 2000, November 22nd has been recognized as National Housing Day in Canada – a day to reflect on the importance of housing to everyone and to raise awareness of the human right to housing.
Despite the decades of tireless advocacy efforts by diverse communities across the country, unfortunately, Canada’s housing and homelessness crises have only gotten worse since the inaugural National Housing Day.
Renters are among the hardest hit by the housing crisis, which threatens their right to secure, affordable and adequate housing. Across the country, renters struggle to find and keep homes they can afford. The most recent data shows that over 20 per cent of renters are in core housing need, meaning they are unable to find good homes that cost less than 30 per cent of their income and are currently living in homes that are overcrowded, in major disrepair, or which are unaffordable. Many groups are disproportionately affected and face higher than average rates of core housing need, in particular Indigenous people, women-led families, newcomers, lone-parents, racialized individuals, and people with disabilities.
Despite the depth of the housing crisis, policy measures and investments in deeply affordable housing have failed to meet the need.
Provincial and territorial housing laws are a patchwork, leaving renters across Canada without the same protections against excessive rent increases, arbitrary evictions, discrimination and other measures to help secure their right to housing. Recognizing the need and in response to the outcry of renters demanding their rights, the federal government introduced a Blueprint for a Renters’ Bill of Rights in September 2024, which outlines a “policy approach for fair and well-functioning renting systems” that aims to align with the right to adequate housing. The document makes it clear that all orders of government in Canada bear a responsibility for fulfilling the right to housing by investing in affordable housing. It also recognizes the need to strengthen current renter protections. Unfortunately, the Renters’ Bill of Rights lacks teeth to raise the standard of rights and protections for renters across the country.
On November 20, hundreds of people from across Canada joined our National Panel Discussion to build a renter-led vision for the Renters’ Bill of Rights.
Speakers from the National Right to Housing Network (NRHN), the Accelerating Accessibility Coalition (AAC), the National Association of Friendship Centres (NAFC), ACORN Canada and the Canadian Centre for Housing Rights (CCHR) outlined what the government could do to better protect renters through a stronger and more robust Renters’ Bill of Rights.
Michèle Biss, National Director of NRHN, highlighted that Canada has an obligation under international human rights law to realize the right to adequate housing and that the Renters’ Bill of Rights is an opportunity for all orders of government in Canada to enact concrete measures in line with those obligations.
The right to adequate housing includes the right of everyone to homes which are accessible, safe, adequate and affordable, where they can live in security, peace, and with dignity. The need for accessible housing for the more than 25 per cent of Canadians with disabilities was underscored by Nikoletta Erdelyi, of Spinal Cord Injury Ontario and AAC.
Gaelle Mushyirahamwe of NAFC explained the colonial roots of the housing crisis for Indigenous renters and called for Indigenous-led housing policies to end the dire housing problems facing Indigenous peoples, including discrimination in the rental market.
Renters are continuing to come together to assert their rights. Tanya Burkart of ACORN Canada shared her experience working with other low and moderate income renters to oppose the financialization of housing and press governments for rent regulation and other measures to protect renters.
Attendees of the panel described the many challenges they face as renters, including discrimination and harassment by landlords, threats of eviction, and rents that continue to rise out of reach. They also highlighted the need for strong and immediate action by our governments to protect renters’ right to housing.
CCHR has been working hard to ensure that the same priorities outlined by the speakers and attendees of our National Panel Discussion were reflected in the Renters’ Bill of Rights. Before its release, we worked with housing advocates across Canada to develop recommendations to guide the development of the Renters’ Bill of Rights. We called on the federal government to take a human rights-based approach that reflected the key elements of the right to housing, backed by protections for renters and investments in truly affordable housing. We also emphasized that these rights must be enforced and upheld with clear accountability mechanisms and that they must apply to all renters across the country.
More than ever, renters need policies and protections that can ensure that everyone in Canada, regardless of where they live, has an adequate, accessible, and affordable place to call home. A stronger Renters’ Bill of Rights could help make that a reality – but only if it truly reflects renters’ experiences and is grounded in the human right to housing.
As we move forward into 2025, we will continue to work with renters and housing advocates across the country to improve the Renters’ Bill of Rights and give renters something to celebrate next year, on the 25th anniversary of National Housing Day.
We hope you join us. Sign up to receive updates about how you can get involved.

Depuis l’an 2000, le 22 novembre est reconnu comme la Journée nationale de l’habitation au Canada – une journée de réflexion autour de l’importance du logement pour tous et de sensibilisation sur le droit au logement.
Malgré des décennies d’efforts de plaidoyer inlassables menés par divers groupes partout au pays, les crises du logement et de l’itinérance au Canada n’ont malheureusement fait qu’empirer depuis la première Journée nationale de l’habitation.
Les locataires sont parmi les plus durement touchés par la crise du logement, qui menace leur droit à un logement adéquat, abordable et sécuritaire. Partout au Canada, les locataires ont du mal à trouver et à conserver des logements qu’ils ont la capacité de payer. Les données les plus récentes montrent que plus de 20 % des locataires ont des besoins impérieux en logement, ce qui signifie qu’ils sont incapables de trouver de bons logements qui coûtent moins de 30% de leur revenu. Le résultat est que les locataires vivent actuellement dans des logements inabordables, surpeuplés ou dans un état de délabrement important. De nombreux groupes sont touchés de façon disproportionnée et font face à des taux plus élevés que la moyenne au niveau des besoins impérieux en logement, en particulier les personnes Autochtones, les familles dirigées par des femmes, les familles monoparentales, les nouveaux arrivants, les personnes racisées et les personnes handicapées.
Malgré l’ampleur de la crise du logement, les mesures gouvernementales et le niveau d’investissements dans les logements à but non-lucratif ne répondent toujours pas aux besoins des locataires.
Les lois provinciales et territoriales sur le logement sont inégales d’une administration à l’autre, et les locataires du Canada ne jouissent pas des mêmes protections contre les augmentations de loyer excessives, les expulsions arbitraires ou la discrimination, et sont laissés sans autres mesures garantir leur droit au logement. Reconnaissant ce besoin, et en réponse à l’indignation des locataires qui réclament leurs droits, le gouvernement fédéral a présenté en septembre 2024 un plan directeur pour une Charte des droits des locataires, qui décrit une « approche stratégique pour la mise en œuvre de régimes de location équitables, efficaces » qui vise à s’aligner sur le droit à un logement adéquat. Le document indique clairement que tous les ordres de gouvernement au Canada ont la responsabilité de réaliser le droit au logement en investissant dans le logement abordable. Il reconnaît également la nécessité de renforcer les protections actuelles des locataires. Malheureusement, la Charte des droits des locataires manque de mordant pour élever les normes relatives aux droits de la personne et pour renforcer les protections pour les locataires à travers le pays.
Le 20 novembre, des centaines de personnes de partout au Canada se sont jointes à notre table ronde nationale pour élaborer une vision conçue par les locataires pour la Charte des droits des locataires.
Des conférenciers du Réseau national pour le droit au logement (RNDL), de l’Accelerating Accessibility Coalition (AAC), de l’Association nationale des centres d’amitié (ANCA), d‘ACORN Canada et du Centre Canadien du droit au logement (CCDL) ont discuté de ce que le gouvernement pourrait faire pour mieux protéger les locataires grâce à une Charte des droits des locataires plus forte et plus robuste.
Michèle Biss, directrice nationale du RNDL, a souligné que, en vertu du droit international, le Canada a l’obligation de réaliser le droit à un logement convenable et que la Charte des droits des locataires est une occasion pour tous les ordres de gouvernement d’adopter des mesures concrètes conformes à ces obligations.
Le droit à un logement convenable comprend le droit de chacun à des logements accessibles, sûrs, adéquats et abordables, où chacun peut vivre dans la sécurité, la paix et la dignité. Le besoin de logements accessibles pour plus de 25 % des Canadiens en situation de handicap a été mis en évidence par Nikoletta Erdelyi, de Lésions médullaires Ontario et de l’AAC.
Gaelle Mushyirahamwe, d’ANCA, a expliqué les racines coloniales de la crise du logement pour les locataires autochtones et a appelé à des politiques de logement menées par les communautés autochtones pour mettre fin aux graves problèmes de logement auxquels sont confrontés les peuples autochtones, y compris la discrimination sur le marché locatif.
Les locataires continuent de se mobiliser pour faire valoir leurs droits. Tanya Burkart d’ACORN Canada a partagé son expérience de travail avec les locataires à faible et modeste revenus pour s’opposer à la financiarisation du logement et faire pression sur les gouvernements pour qu’ils réglementent les loyers et prennent des mesures additionnelles pour protéger les locataires.
Les participants à l’évènement ont décrit les nombreux défis auxquels ils sont confrontés en tant que locataires, comme la discrimination et le harcèlement de la part de certains propriétaires, les menaces d’expulsion et les loyers qui continuent d’augmenter à vitesse vertigineuse. Ils ont également souligné la nécessité d’une action forte et immédiate de la part de nos gouvernements pour protéger le droit au logement des locataires.
Le CCDL a travaillé fort pour s’assurer que les mêmes priorités énoncées par les conférenciers et les participants à notre table ronde nationale étaient reflétées dans la Charte des droits des locataires. Avant sa publication, nous nous sommes concertés avec des défenseurs du droit au logement de tout le pays pour formuler des recommandations afin d’orienter l’élaboration de la Charte des droits des locataires. Nous avons demandé au gouvernement fédéral d’adopter une approche fondée sur les droits de la personne qui reflète les éléments clés du droit au logement, appuyée par des protections pour les locataires et des investissements dans des logements véritablement abordables. Nous avons également insisté sur le fait que ces droits doivent être appliqués et respectés au l’aide de mécanismes de responsabilisation clairs et qu’ils doivent s’appliquer à tous les locataires du pays.
Plus que jamais, les locataires ont besoin de politiques et de protections qui peuvent faire en sorte que tout le monde au Canada ait un logement adéquat, accessible et abordable, peu importe où ils vivent. Une Charte des droits des locataires plus forte pourrait aider à faire de cette vision une réalité, mais seulement si elle reflète vraiment les expériences vécues des locataires et est fondée sur le droit humain au logement.
Alors que nous nous apprêtons à amorcer l’an 2025, nous continuerons de travailler avec les locataires et les défenseurs du droit au logement à travers le pays pour améliorer la Charte des droits des locataires et donner aux locataires quelque chose à célébrer l’année prochaine, à l’occasion du 25e anniversaire de la Journée nationale de l’habitation.
Nous espérons que vous vous joindrez à nous. Inscrivez-vous pour recevoir des mises à jour sur la façon dont vous pouvez vous impliquer.
NATIONAL
PROVINCIAL / TERRITORIAL
Nova Scotia
Prince Edward Island
Ontario
Saskatchewan
British Columbia
Yukon
MUNICIPAL / LOCAL
The Canadian Centre for Housing Rights (CCHR) partnered with CT Labs and several local partners in Saskatoon on a project funded by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) Solutions Lab, to understand and estimate hidden homelessness in Saskatoon.
Hidden homelessness is experienced by many people across the country, but there has been great difficulty in understanding the extent of the problem as it is an invisible form of homelessness. CCHR developed a pilot project in Saskatoon to understand and enumerate hidden homelessness, in order to better serve the housing needs of those who are invisibly unhoused. Using Saskatoon as a case study, the project produced a framework for estimating the scope of hidden homelessness and developing effective solutions, that can be used by policymakers and service providers in similar urban centers across Canada. To do this, we brought together stakeholders from across Saskatoon’s housing system to capture the journeys of those experiencing hidden homelessness and co-develop innovative strategies for collecting data to create evidence-based solutions.
The Understanding and Estimating Hidden Homelessness in Saskatoon project received funding from Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) under the NHS Solutions Labs, however, the views expressed are the personal views of the author and CMHC accepts no responsibility for them.
CMHC’s Solutions Labs are an innovative approach to tackling complex societal challenges that cannot be solved by one organization or sector. Using bottom-up collaboration, they provide a safe space for diverse perspectives to come together, for assumptions to be questioned, and for community-based solutions to be created. They are one of the tools under the National Housing Strategy being used to inform decision-making at all levels of government.
NATIONAL
PROVINCIAL / TERRITORIAL
British Columbia
NOVA scotia
ONTARIO
QUEBEC
Yukon
MUNICIPAL / LOCAL
The National Right to Housing Network, the Canadian Centre for Housing Rights, and Professor Sarah Buhler at the University of Saskatchewan are proud to partner on a research project exploring a human rights and youth-centred approach to eviction law and practice, with the aim of reducing youth evictions and taking seriously the lived expertise, human rights, and unique circumstances of youth.
In Canada, children and youth experience eviction from rental housing at higher rates than most other age groups. Eviction is particularly damaging for youth because of its long-term consequences and propensity to entangle youth with other systems. Eviction into homelessness is also a violation of international human rights law. Yet Canadian eviction laws do not reflect human rights obligations or account for the unique experiences and vulnerabilities of youth. Instead, tribunals often function as “eviction machines.”
Using a human rights and youth-centred lens, this project will explore the following three research questions:

Keeping Youth Housed: Preventing Youth Evictions Through Law
Meaningful engagement is a critical part of a human rights-based approach to addressing systemic housing issues. In the spring of 2024, housing and youth advocates and youth with lived expertise in Toronto and Saskatoon joined workshops to engage in our research. This report provides a real-life example of what meaningful engagement looks like in practice.

The report outlines our methodology behind the workshops and how we meaningfully engaged with participants as they shared their stories and ideas on how a world without eviction could look like.

We are urging the Federal Housing Advocate to lead a review on the issue of youth evictions, and develop recommendations for the federal government to address. Our recommendations aim to support the development of a re-imagined and transformed approach to eviction and tenant legal systems rooted in commitments to prevent eviction and uphold human rights.
This work is funded by Making the Shift Youth Homelessness Social Innovation Lab (MtS), a member of the Government of Canada’s Networks of Centres of Excellence program. Making the Shift funds, conducts, prototypes, and mobilizes cutting-edge research to prevent and end youth homelessness in Canada.
Cet article est aussi disponible en français

On September 16, 2024, the federal government released a Blueprint for a Renters’ Bill of Rights – an important measure that could move the needle on Canada’s housing affordability crisis by establishing national standards that protect housing stability and affordability for renters across the country.
The Renters’ Bill of Rights comes at a critical time, as Canada remains in the midst of an escalating housing crisis, where renters face soaring rental costs, few affordable options, and increasing levels of housing insecurity. Without adequate and consistent national standards to protect against excessive rents, arbitrary and unnecessary evictions, renovictions, disrepair, discrimination, and many other issues, renters are increasingly facing housing precarity and homelessness.
Landlord and tenant matters in Canada are governed by provincial and territorial residential tenancy legislation, and as a result, the rights and protections afforded to renters vary widely across Canada. For example, in half of Canada’s provinces and territories, rent increases are not regulated at all. In others, rent increases are regulated to a certain extent, but the rules do not apply to all renters, leaving many, in particular long-standing tenants, vulnerable to economically-motivated evictions.
Unequal housing laws across the country have contributed to a crisis where renters are struggling like never before. Building more market-rate housing will not help them right now when they need it most, but implementing national standards to protect the affordability and security of their current homes will. With the Renters’ Bill of Rights, the federal government has seized a critical opportunity to ensure that every renter in Canada is afforded the same baseline rights when it comes to their housing.
Over the past few months, the Canadian Centre for Housing Rights (CCHR) collaborated with housing advocates and leaders from across Canada to develop our key recommendations for what a strong Renters Bill of Rights must include. Below, we have outlined these key recommendations, our assessment of the government’s blueprint, and highlighted upcoming opportunities for communities to support the establishment of strong standard protections for renters across the country.
In consultation with housing advocates and leaders across the country, we developed the following principles and scope of rights and protections that would ensure a comprehensive, impactful, and robust Renters’ Bill of Rights
Three core principles must guide the development and implementation of standard renter protections across the country:
Building on these core principles, our specific recommendations are presented in six groupings that reflect the elements of the right to housing, as well as the principles of equity, equality, and access to justice:
The cost of housing should not interfere with renters’ ability to access other human rights (such as food), and should be reflective of household incomes, rather than tightly wedded to market forces. Rent increases must be moderate and predictable throughout and between tenancies, so that the cost of housing does not continue to interfere with the right of all Canadians to a secure home and a decent standard of living. To uphold affordability, at a minimum, the Renters’ Bill of Rights should include the:
Eviction is a grave measure that leads to displacement and can result in homelessness. Eviction has very serious social, financial and psychological repercussions on individuals and families, and equity-deserving groups are most at risk. It follows that eviction should always be understood and treated as a last resort. In cases where a renter must vacate their rental home temporarily for renovations or repairs, rental agreements should not end, except by consent, and renters should be provided with adequate relocation and/or compensation until they are able to return to their home. To uphold security of tenure, at a minimum, the Renters’ Bill of Rights should include:
Housing providers must maintain rental homes in a state of good repair, ensure renters have access to all necessary services, and that they are safe from health, structural, and other hazards, including those resulting from changing climate. To uphold habitability and availability of services, at a minimum, the Renters’ Bill of Rights should include:
Renters should have access to housing that meets their needs, and a Renters’ Bill of Rights should recognize the broad range of accessibility requirements related to physical, intellectual, mental, and other types of disabilities. The unique needs of renters must also be respected, in particular for renters from Indigenous, Black, newcomer, immigrant, and other racialized and equity-deserving communities. To uphold accessibility and cultural adequacy, at a minimum, the Renters’ Bill of Rights should include:
Renters should experience equitable treatment and freedom from discrimination, harassment, and other threats, both in seeking and maintaining their housing. Renters should also be free to enjoy their rental home without invasion of privacy or other undue interference from their housing provider or other renters. To uphold equity and equality, at a minimum, the Renters’ Bill of Rights should include:
Renters should have access to enforcement and accountability mechanisms that ensure they benefit from protections in place and that account for the inherent power imbalance between renters and housing providers. To uphold access to justice, at a minimum, the Renters’ Bill of Rights should include:
CCHR and our partners have emphasized to the federal government the importance of developing the Renters’ Bill of Rights in consultation with renter communities, advocates and civil society to ensure these protections truly address the needs of renters and reflect their voices.
In August 2024, CCHR surveyed tenant groups and housing organizations from across Canada, collecting their input on the rights that should be included in the Renters’ Bill of Rights, based on the list of rights outlined above.
We received over 50 responses from eight jurisdictions across the country. The vast majority of respondents strongly endorsed the above list of rights, and provided some helpful context and recommendations around the importance of these rights and actions that governments could take to implement them. Common themes from the survey results reflected the need for a comprehensive suite of renter protections with robust accountability and enforcement mechanisms, including:
While respondents were overwhelmingly supportive of stronger renter protections across the country, some also expressed skepticism around the likelihood of their provincial or territorial government adopting and/or enforcing these protections. To be sure, the implementation of the Renters’ Bill of Rights will require cooperation between different levels of government. However, we have reason to be optimistic that this can be achieved, as this type of intergovernmental cooperation is not unprecedented. For example, over the course of 20 years after it was introduced by the federal government, the National Building Code was adopted by every province and territory as a standard for building design and construction.
Given the context, it will be incumbent on the federal government to adopt strategies that will ensure provinces and territories adopt and uphold these critical renter protections at a time when Canadians need them most. Likewise, renter advocates and organizations have a key role to play in encouraging adoption, and holding governments accountable for their responsibility to ensure equal and consistent rights for renters across the country.
The release of the Renters’ Bill of Rights blueprint is a significant step in the right direction, signaling that the federal government understands that uneven and precarious protections for renters are inadequate, and that renters are suffering as a result. The blueprint outlines a range of important measures that if implemented consistently across the country, would improve fairness, equality, access, and affordability for renters, including:
Importantly, the blueprint is framed around the shared responsibilities of federal, provincial, and territorial governments to advance the right to adequate housing, including through sufficient investments in non-market, affordable housing. The federal government will encourage uptake by provinces and territories through tying the Renters’ Bill Rights to a new Canada Housing Infrastructure Fund. Provinces and territories can only access the $5 billion available through this fund if they implement measures from the Renters’ Bill of Rights and Home Buyers’ Bill of Rights.
In the coming months, it will be critical that they follow through to ensure the adoption of these standards by providing strong incentives, direction and accountability mechanisms. While it is encouraging to see that provinces and territories will be required to report on their progress to advance renters’ rights, it is currently unclear what mechanisms will be in place to ensure that these essential standards will be enforced across the country and we look forward to hearing more on this.
The Renters’ Bill of Rights is the most concrete way that governments can improve housing stability and prevent homelessness for those most at risk right now. Its adoption across the country must become a key priority for the government. Commitments to build more market-based housing as a strategy to address the affordability issues may sound logical, but the reality is these measures are simply not an adequate response to the crisis that is ravaging lower income communities. It is well understood that in the absence of robust affordability requirements, new private market housing will not be affordable, especially for low- and moderate-income residents. Studies have shown that increasing supply does not meaningfully lower rents in existing homes, and in some cases, can have the opposite effect.
In the coming months, we hope to see strong incentives for the adoption of the Renters’ Bill of Rights alongside government-led public consultations. CCHR views the Renters’ Bill of Rights as a critical opportunity to ensure there are equal protections for renters across the country – something that should have been in place a long time ago.
We will be organizing a series of public workshops across the country this fall to raise awareness of its importance and mobilize communities to advocate for a robust Renters’ Bill of Rights to address the challenges and inequities facing renters across Canada, with concrete actions that hold all levels of government accountable for upholding renters’ rights.
Le 16 septembre 2024, le gouvernement fédéral a publié un Plan pour une Charte des droits des locataires, une mesure importante qui pourrait faire avancer le droit au logement au Canada en établissant des normes nationales qui protègent la stabilité et l’abordabilité du logement pour les locataires partout au pays.
La Charte des droits des locataires arrive à un moment critique, alors que le Canada est en pleine crise du logement, avec des loyers en forte hausse, peu d’options abordables et une insécurité du logement croissante. En l’absence de normes nationales adéquates et cohérentes pour se protéger contre les loyers excessifs, les évictions arbitraires et inutiles, le délabrement, les rénovictions, la discrimination et bien d’autres défis, les locataires sont de plus en plus confrontés à la précarité dans le logement et à l’itinérance.
Les questions relatives aux ententes entre propriétaires et aux locataires au Canada sont régies par les lois provinciales et territoriales sur la location résidentielle et, par conséquent, les droits et les protections accordés aux locataires varient considérablement à travers le Canada. Par exemple, dans la moitié des provinces et des territoires, les augmentations de loyer ne sont pas du tout réglementées. Dans d’autres, les augmentations de loyer sont réglementées dans une certaine mesure, mais les règles ne s’appliquent pas à tous les locataires, ce qui rend nombre d’entre eux vulnérables aux évictions motivées par des raisons économiques, en particulier les locataires de longue date.
Les disparités entre les lois sur le logement d’une province à l’autre ont contribué à une crise où les locataires rencontrent des difficultés sans précédent. Construire davantage de logements au prix du marché ne les aidera pas maintenant, au moment où ils en ont le plus besoin, mais la mise en œuvre de normes nationales visant à protéger l’abordabilité et la sécurité de leurs logements actuels le fera. Avec la Charte des droits des locataires, le gouvernement fédéral a saisi une occasion cruciale de garantir que chaque locataire au Canada bénéficie des mêmes droits de base en matière de logement.
Au cours des derniers mois, le Centre Canadien du droit au logement (CCDL) a collaboré avec des défenseurs et des experts en droit au logement de partout au Canada pour élaborer un ensemble de recommandations sur ce que doit inclure une solide Charte des droits des locataires. Ci-dessous, nous avons décrit ces principales recommandations, notre évaluation du plan directeur du gouvernement et mis en lumière les opportunités pour le milieu communautaire de soutenir l’établissement de normes minimales de protection pour les locataires du Canada.
En consultation avec les défenseurs et les experts en droit au logement, nous avons proposé les principes suivants et défini leur champ d’application aux droits et protections qui garantiraient une Charte des droits des locataires complète, efficace et solide.
Trois principes fondamentaux doivent guider l’élaboration et la mise en œuvre de mesures de protection standards pour les locataires Canadiens :
S’appuyant sur ces principes fondamentaux, nos recommandations particulières sont déclinées en six points qui reflètent les éléments du droit au logement, ainsi que les principes d’équité, d’égalité et d’accès à la justice :
Le coût du logement ne devrait pas interférer avec la capacité des locataires à jouir de leurs autres droits (comme le droit à une alimentation suffisante) et devrait refléter les niveaux de revenus des ménages, plutôt que d’être soumis aux forces du marché. Les augmentations de loyer doivent être modérées et prévisibles tout au long et entre les ententes de locations, afin que le coût du logement n’entrave pas le droit de tous les Canadiens à une sécurité du logement et à un niveau de vie décent. Pour maintenir l’abordabilité dans le logement, la Charte des droits des locataires devrait inclure au minimum les éléments suivants :
L’éviction est une mesure grave qui entraîne le déplacement des habitants et peut mener à l’itinérance. Les évictions ont de très graves répercussions sociales, financières et psychologiques sur les individus et les familles, et les groupes méritant l’équité sont les plus vulnérables. Par conséquent, les évictions doivent toujours être comprises et traitées comme une mesure de dernier ressort. Dans le cas où un locataire doit temporairement quitter son logement pour cause de rénovations ou réparations, le bail ne devrait pas prendre fin, sauf par consentement mutuel, et les locataires devraient bénéficier d’une relocalisation temporaire ou d’une indemnisation suffisante jusqu’à ce qu’ils soient en mesure de réinvestir leur logement. Pour garantir la sécurité d’occupation, la Charte des droits des locataires devrait inclure au minimum les éléments suivants :
Les fournisseurs de logements doivent maintenir leurs logements locatifs en bon état, s’assurer que les locataires ont accès à tous les services nécessaires et qu’ils sont à l’abri de tous risques qui pourraient menacer leur santé, dangers structurels et autres risques, y compris les risques liés au changement climatique. Pour garantir l’habitabilité et la disponibilité des services, la Charte des droits des locataires devrait inclure au minimum les éléments suivants :
Les locataires devraient avoir accès à un logement qui réponde à leurs besoins, et la Charte des droits des locataires devrait reconnaître le large éventail d’exigences en matière d’accessibilité liées aux handicaps physiques, intellectuels, mentaux et autres. Les besoins uniques des locataires doivent être respectés, en particulier ceux des locataires issus de communautés autochtones, noires ou racisées, nouveaux arrivants, immigrants et autres groupes privés d’équité. Pour garantir l’accessibilité et l’adéquation culturelle dans le logement, la Charte des droits des locataires devrait inclure au minimum les éléments suivants :
Les locataires doivent bénéficier d’un traitement équitable et être à l’abri de toute forme de discrimination, harcèlement et autres menaces, tant dans la recherche de leur logement que durant son occupation. Les locataires devraient également être libres de profiter de leur logement sans qu’il y ait atteinte à leur vie privée ni ingérence excessive de la part de leur fournisseur de logement ou d’autres locataires. Pour maintenir l’équité et l’égalité dans le logement, la Charte des droits des locataires devrait inclure au minimum les éléments suivants :
Les locataires devraient avoir accès à des mécanismes d’application de la loi et de responsabilisation qui garantissent qu’ils bénéficient des protections en place et qui tiennent compte du déséquilibre de pouvoir inhérent entre locataires et fournisseurs de logements. Pour garantir l’accès à la justice, la Charte des droits des locataires devrait inclure au minimum les éléments suivants :
Le CCDL et ses partenaires ont fait valoir au gouvernement fédéral l’importance d’élaborer la Charte des droits des locataires en consultation avec les groupes de locataires, les défenseurs du droit au logement et la société civile pour garantir que ces protections répondent véritablement aux besoins des locataires et reflètent leur opinion.
En août 2024, le CCDL a sondé des groupes de locataires et des organismes de défense du droit au logement de partout au Canada, et a recueilli leurs commentaires sur les droits qui devraient être inclus dans la Charte, suivant la liste des droits décrite plus haut.
Nous avons reçu plus de 50 réponses en provenance de huit provinces et territoires. La grande majorité des répondants ont fortement approuvé la liste de droits proposée par le CCDL et ont fourni des informations sur leur contexte et des recommandations utiles sur l’importance de ces droits et sur les mesures que leurs gouvernements pourraient prendre pour les mettre en œuvre. Les thèmes communs issus des résultats de l’enquête reflètent la nécessité d’une série complète de mesures de protection des locataires, dotées de mécanismes de responsabilisation et d’application de la loi robustes, notamment :
Bien que les répondants soient largement favorables à des mesures de protection plus fortes pour tous les locataires du Canada, certains ont également exprimé des doutesquant à la probabilité que leur gouvernement provincial ou territorial adopte ou applique ces mesures de protection. Il est certain que la mise en œuvre de la Charte des droits des locataires nécessitera une coopération étroite entre les différents paliers de gouvernement. Nous avons cependant des raisons d’être optimistes quant à la possibilité d’y parvenir, car ce type de coopération intergouvernementale n’est pas sans précédent. Par exemple, au cours des 20 années qui ont suivi son introduction par le gouvernement fédéral, le Code national du bâtiment a été adopté par chaque province et territoire comme standard de conception et de construction des bâtiments.
Compte tenu du contexte actuel, il incombera au gouvernement fédéral d’adopter des stratégies qui garantiront que les provinces et les territoires adoptent et maintiennent ces protections essentielles pour les locataires à un moment où les Canadiens en ont le plus besoin. De même, les groupes et organismes de défense du droit au logement ont un rôle clé à jouer pour encourager l’adoption de ces protections et tenir les gouvernements responsables de leur devoir de garantir des droits égaux et cohérents pour tous les locataires du Canada.
La publication du Plan pour une Charte des droits des locataires constitue un pas en avant significatif, qui montre que le gouvernement fédéral comprend que des protections inégales et précaires pour les locataires sont inadéquates et que ces derniers en souffrent. Le plan présente une série de mesures importantes qui, si elles étaient mises en œuvre de manière cohérente dans tout le pays, amélioreraient l’équité, l’égalité, l’abordabilité et un meilleuraccès au logement pour les locataires, notamment les mesures suivantes :
Il est important de noter que le plan directeur s’articule autour des responsabilités communes des gouvernements fédéral, provinciaux et territoriaux pour faire progresser le droit à un logement décent, notamment par des investissements suffisants dans le logement abordable et à but non-lucratif. Le gouvernement fédéral compte encourager l’adoption de cette mesure par les provinces et les territoires en liant la Charte des droits des locataires à un nouveau Fonds canadien pour les infrastructures liées au logement. Les provinces et territoires ne pourront accéder aux 5 milliards de dollars disponibles dans le cadre de ce fonds seulement s’ils mettent en œuvre les mesures contenues dans la Charte des droits des locataires et dans la Charte des droits des acheteurs d’une propriété.
Dans les mois à venir, il sera essentiel que les gouvernements provinciaux et territoriaux prennent les mesures nécessaires pour garantir l’adoption de ces normes en fournissant des mesures incitatives, de l’orientation et des mécanismes de responsabilisation solides. Bien qu’il soit encourageant de constater que les provinces et territoires seront tenus de rendre compte de leurs progrès en lien avec l’avancement des droits des locataires, on ne sait pas encore quels mécanismes seront mis en place pour garantir que ces normes essentielles soient appliquées dans tout le pays et nous attendons avec intérêt d’en apprendre plus à ce sujet.
La Charte des droits des locataires est le moyen le plus concret dont disposent les gouvernements pour améliorer la sécurité du logement et prévenir l’itinérance chez les personnes les plus vulnérables. Son adoption à l’échelle du pays doit devenir une priorité absolue pour le gouvernement. Les engagements visant à construire davantage de logements au prix du marché comme stratégie pour résoudre les problèmes d’abordabilité peuvent sembler logiques, mais la réalité est que ces mesures ne constituent tout simplement pas une réponse adéquate à la crise qui ravage les communautés à faible revenus. Il va de soi qu’en l’absence d’exigences rigoureuses en matière d’abordabilité, les logements neufs construits par le marché privé ne seront pas abordables, en particulier pour les résidents à revenus faibles et modérés. Des études ont montré que l’augmentation de l’offre ne réduit pas de manière significative les loyers des logements existants et, dans certains cas, peut avoir l’effet inverse.
Dans les mois à venir, nous espérons que l’adoption de la Charte des droits des locataires sera fortement encouragée, parallèlement aux consultations publiques qui seront menées par le gouvernement. Le CCDL considère la Charte des droits des locataires comme une occasion cruciale de garantir des protections égales pour les locataires à travers le pays, quelque chose qui aurait dû être mis en place il y a longtemps.
Nous organiserons une série d’ateliers publics d’envergure nationale cet automne pour sensibiliser et mobiliser le milieu communautaire afin de plaider en faveur d’une Charte des droits des locataires solide pour relever les défis et les inégalités auxquels font face les locataires partout au Canada, avec des mesures concrètes qui tiennent tous les niveaux de gouvernement responsables quant au respect des droits des locataires.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Toronto, ON – September 16, 2024 – Today, the federal government released a new Blueprint for a Renters’ Bill of Rights – a critical measure that could help address Canada’s housing affordability crisis by strengthening protections for renters across the country.
The blueprint includes a range of important measures that aim to improve fairness, equality, access and affordability for renters. It also makes clear that the federal, provincial and territorial governments are all responsible for fulfilling the right to housing of all Canadians, which requires improving the renting system across the country. This includes adequately investing in affordable housing that meets the needs of renters. However, despite some reporting requirements, the blueprint falls short of providing strong direction and accountability mechanisms to ensure that provincial and territorial governments will fulfill their responsibilities.
“It’s promising to see many measures in the Renters’ Bill of Rights blueprint that would help level the playing field between landlords and renters,” says Sara Beyer, Manager of Policy at the Canadian Centre for Housing Rights (CCHR). “However, currently it lacks the strong federal direction needed to ensure that these critical protections for renters will actually be realized. Without requiring provinces and territories to amend their laws to ensure rents are well-regulated and that eviction is treated as a last resort, we’re concerned that the Renters’ Bill of Rights will be a missed opportunity to curb rising rental costs, and prevent evictions and homelessness.”
Public opinion polls by Leger and Abacus Data from the past year show that an overwhelming majority of Canadians view the housing affordability crisis as a serious problem, yet they do not feel that our governments are taking the necessary steps to tackle the crisis. Likewise, in a recent survey conducted by CCHR of over 50 tenant groups and housing organizations across the country, the vast majority agree that strong renter protections are essential to tackling the housing affordability crisis. Yet, many are skeptical that their provincial or territorial government would enact any of the measures necessary to ensure renters can afford to stay in their homes and that they do not face excessive rent increases or unfair evictions.
Renter protections vary significantly depending on where you live in the country. The Renters’ Bill of Rights provides a key opportunity for all levels of government to work together to ensure that all renters – no matter where they live – enjoy the same rights and protections, for which CCHR has long advocated. If the federal government gave the Renters’ Bill of Rights real teeth, it has the potential to make a meaningful impact on the housing affordability crisis and address systemic issues related to inadequate and disparate protections for renters across the country.
Media contact:
Shelley Buckingham
Director of Communications, Canadian Centre for Housing Rights
Email: media [at] housingrightscanada.com
NATIONAL
ATLANTIC CANADA
NOVA SCOTIA
PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND
CENTRAL CANADA
ONTARIO
QUEBEC
WESTERN CANADA
MANITOBA
SASKATCHEWAN
Alberta
British Columbia
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Toronto, ON – July 23, 2024 – A new report released by the Canadian Centre for Housing Rights (CCHR) finds that Ontario’s high housing costs are a significant barrier preventing survivors of gender-based violence (GBV) and intimate partner violence (IPV) from finding a safe home, free from violence.
The report presents key findings from CCHR’s research study in five Ontario communities – Toronto, Ottawa, Peterborough, Thunder Bay and Lanark County. Through interviews with 28 service providers and a survey of 102 women and gender-diverse people who have experienced GBV and IPV (survivors), along with an analysis of local housing market conditions, the study fills a knowledge gap in understanding the relationship between GBV and housing insecurity in Ontario.
The study found that unaffordable housing costs in their community prevented 79 per cent of survivors from leaving the residence where they experienced violence. For those who sought a temporary safe place in an emergency shelter, 65 per cent experienced housing insecurity after leaving the shelter. Due to a lack of affordable housing, survivors are facing difficult housing choices, and 17 per cent of survivors surveyed had no other option but to return to live with their abuser.
“Sometimes it’s easier to stay in an abusive situation than to be on the streets. As long as it was just me suffering the abuse, I would rather that than my kids not have a warm bed and hot meal in their belly,” said one survivor.
The study also found that 42 per cent of survivors experience discrimination when searching for housing in the private market, particularly based on their race, Indigeneity, gender, sexual orientation, disability and receipt of social assistance. Due in part to this high degree of discrimination and a lack of affordable housing options, only 10 per cent of survivors who had accessed emergency shelters were able to find a home in the private rental housing market.
In addition, the study found that existing shelter, income and other community supports are not meeting the diverse needs of survivors, particularly for people with disabilities, gender-diverse people, Indigenous people, newcomers and people with children.
“We get people substance abuse help, we get them mental health help, we get them safety planning and we get them, you know, court support. But the reality is if they have nowhere to land to receive those services and actually process the service provision, it’s not helpful,” said one frontline worker.
To address these issues, the report outlines several urgent policy measures that the federal and provincial governments must take to improve the housing conditions of survivors of GBV and IPV. These include implementing affordability measures, addressing gaps in services and supports for people fleeing violence, addressing discrimination, and prioritizing those in greatest need, namely Indigenous and gender-diverse people.
“These findings are deeply alarming but are unfortunately not surprising given how challenging the housing situation has become in Ontario for so many people.” said CCHR Researcher Sophie O’Manique. “The intersection between the GBV epidemic and the housing crisis is putting so many survivors in an impossible situation where they must choose between remaining in an abusive household or being housed. We hope that this research can help to amplify the voices of survivors and others in the sector that are raising alarm bells to push for much needed change and informs policy solutions that our governments must implement with urgency.”
Quick facts:
Media contact:
Shelley Buckingham
Director of Communications, Canadian Centre for Housing Rights
Email: media [at] housingrightscanada.com
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.